If the very mention of the word “pizza” makes you hungry for melted cheese and tasty toppings, then you ought to check out some of AMI, Florida’s top four pizza spots.
Try these local pizza restaurants while staying in your Anna Maria Island vacation rental. The portions are large, so bring an appetite!
Pizza Social
Many locals say this is the best place for pizza on Anna Maria Island, and it opens for business almost every day (except Tuesday) from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Their staff is highly vetted, friendly, and very knowledgeable about the area should you have any questions or get a little lost while you’re passing by. They can cater on special occasions, too, if you’re here for a wedding or a reunion and can’t resist some cheesy pizza!
If you like hand-crafted pizzas, this is the way to go. Start with an order of the 10-inch Social Pizza, which comes with mozzarella cheese, bell peppers, Italian sausage (or any substitute available, upon request), mushrooms, and red sauce. If you’re a little hungrier (or wish to share with someone), you can get the 14-inch version. Both are top picks here.
Vinny’s Italian Kitchen
Another recommendation for Anna Maria Island pizza is known as “Little Italy in the Heart of Anna Maria Island” (literally — that’s its slogan). It is one of the most easygoing pizza eateries in the area. You may walk in, and the staff may tell a quick joke and make you feel relaxed. Come in, put your mind at ease, and laugh a little. Chef Vincenzo’s got quite a sense of humor and loves what he does; he’s been at it for over 50 years. Come in any day from 11 a.m. to 7 p.m.
Chef welcomes you to try his locally famous Meat Lasagna, an instant dinner hit. One bite is all you need to believe it for yourself. This top-choice dinner plate serves two, as do the Cheese Lasagna and the Pasta Marinara meals. If you prefer a single-person entrée, try his Pasta Marinara Lunch Entrée instead, or perhaps his jaw-dropping Baked Ziti.
Plan Your Visit
Ask any rental expert on our team for their insight, and they can help you land the perfect home on the perfect vacation! Contact us today to get started planning the AMI vacation of a lifetime.
Solo’s Pizza
When you need fast & tasty pizza on Anna Maria Island, Solo’s Pizza has you covered. Open from 4-10 p.m. most days (they’re closed Monday and Tuesday), this triple-threat (dine-in, take-out, and delivery) eatery is popular but never too busy to serve you with a smile.
You can get a cheese pizza with no toppings, a pepperoni pizza with just pepperoni and cheese, or even a full “bite me” pizza that has every single topping on to it. The “Super Deluxe” pizza they offer is loaded just with meats and veggies if you prefer that.
Oma’s Pizza
Many say this is the best pizza on Anna Maria Island: the one and only “Sicilian Oma Special,” small, medium or large. Get it as a single slice for yourself or as a 6-slice/8-slice family combo. It comes with all the essential goodies, like ham, olives, red or green peppers (your choice), sausage, pepperoni, and mushrooms.
Come in from Wednesday through Sunday from 11 a.m. to midnight. You’ll love talking with the staff, as well. They’d love to tell you how this place came to be, not to mention how well it currently serves its diners (with countless photos of happy customers placed on the walls) through its dine-in and pick-up order options. The menu is vast here, too — you can get everything from pizzas and calzones to spaghetti, soups, salads, and even some amazing cannoli desserts. Try their Salami & Cheese Hero Sandwich as well!
Our Anna Maria Island Vacation Rentals
Pick Mike Norman first for your Anna Maria Island rental needs. Our homes are near to all the most beloved Anna Maria Island restaurants, so you won’t have to go far. It only takes a few short minutes by foot or car to travel to the best restaurants Anna Maria Island has to offer. Plus, we offer stunning Anna Maria Island pet friendly rentals! Browse the listings here on our website to find out more.