Some vacation decisions are easy. Beach day? Absolutely. Another sunset walk? Of course. Figuring out where everyone wants to eat dinner? That can take a little more planning.
Luckily, Anna Maria Island has plenty of places to satisfy a seafood craving, whether you’re picturing fresh, local fish on Historic Bridge Street, dinner overlooking the bay, or a casual lunch with your beach bag still in tow.
The best part is that each spot offers a different experience. You can make an evening of cocktails and seafood, bring the family somewhere with live music, or head just over the bridge for lunch in one of the oldest and last remaining commercial fishing villages in Florida.
If you’re looking for Anna Maria Island seafood restaurants to try during your stay, here are some of our favorites to keep on your radar.
Where to Eat Seafood on Anna Maria Island



1. Blue Marlin Seafood
Planning a dinner you’ll actually look forward to getting ready for? Start with Blue Marlin Seafood in Bradenton Beach.
Located on Historic Bridge Street, Blue Marlin sources fresh fish directly from Cortez, which carries through to its dinner menu and daily specials. Fish tacos and Cortez Seafood Chowder are worth a look, and the Lobster Grilled Cheese might make your dinner decision a little harder. Yes, lobster grilled cheese.
The atmosphere is part of the appeal, too. Make time for a drink in the Trap Yard, their outdoor shell yard, and check the live music schedule when planning your visit. It’s an easy way to turn dinner into an evening out without leaving Bridge Street.
Our tip: Reserve your table ahead of time, especially if you wish to visit on the weekends.



2. The Waterfront Restaurant
If your ideal vacation meal includes a breeze off the bay and delicious seafood, add The Waterfront Restaurant to your list.
Located in the City of Anna Maria, the restaurant offers open-air patio views of Tampa Bay and a seasonal menu built around fresh ingredients. Seafood, steaks, salads, and craft cocktails make it an option for groups with all types of taste buds.
Over the years, this cottage has transformed from an art gallery to an ice cream parlor, and eventually a restaurant, and it’s a lovely choice when you want a meal that comes with a little island character. Leave room in your plans to explore the north end before or after you eat.
3. Island Ocean Star
Seafood night doesn’t always have to mean a grouper sandwich.
Island Ocean Star brings Japanese cuisine to the mix, with sushi, sashimi, seafood dishes, and cooked options such as hibachi shrimp and tempura.
Located on South Bay Boulevard in the City of Anna Maria, it’s worth considering when someone in your group asks, “Can we do sushi tonight?” Specialty rolls, including the Fire Island Roll and Green Caterpillar Roll, give you plenty to browse before choosing your order.
Prefer a quiet evening at your vacation rental? Check its online ordering options and make sushi night part of your stay. Sometimes dinner around the kitchen table after a full beach day is exactly what everyone needs.
Related post: 14 Things to Do in Anna Maria Island You’ll Wish You Knew Sooner
4. The Feast
Traveling with someone who wants crab legs, someone who wants pasta, and someone who’s already asking about steak? The Feast in Holmes Beach makes that conversation easier.
Its menu includes Alaskan snow crab, grouper, coconut shrimp, crab cakes, and seafood pasta dishes, alongside steaks and other options. It’s a good place to keep in mind when everyone wants a satisfying dinner, but nobody wants the same thing.
There’s also a fun option for visitors spending a day fishing: The Feast offers a “You Catch, We Cook” service. Bring your catch already filleted, choose your preparation, and let the kitchen take care of dinner.
Our tip: Call ahead before bringing in your fish to confirm the current details on the “You Catch, We Cook” service.


5. Sandbar Seafood & Spirits
If you’re looking for beachfront dining, the Sandbar Seafood & Spirits in the City of Anna Maria is the place to be.
Its beachfront setting makes it a natural choice when the view is a big part of your dinner plans. If you’re hoping to pair dinner with sunset, give yourself extra time to get there and settle in. That’s one meal you won’t want to squeeze between other plans.
For a quicker stop, Sandbar’s Beachside Bites offers a walk-up option with coffee, breakfast and lunch selections, drinks, and grab-and-go bites. Keep it in mind when you want something easy during a beach day.


6. The Ugly Grouper
If you’ve seen a photo of a giant metal fish on Anna Maria Island, there’s a good chance you’ve already been introduced to The Ugly Grouper.
This Holmes Beach restaurant leans into the fun, with outdoor dining, live entertainment, and a family-friendly atmosphere. It’s the place to go when you want dinner to feel relaxed, and the kids could use something more interesting to look at than another restaurant wall.
Grouper tacos are one of the seafood options to check out, with fish and chips and other choices on the menu.
And yes, make time for a photo with the grouper statue. It’s practically part of the visit.
7. Hurricane Hanks
Some days, you just want somewhere comfortable to sit down, order a good meal, and let someone else handle the cooking.
Hurricane Hanks fits that kind of plan. Locally owned and operated since 2000, this Holmes Beach spot focuses on cooking from scratch and offers enough variety to work for a family meal, a lunch stop, or a night out with friends.
For lunch, take a look at the grouper sandwich and Guinness-battered baskets. At dinner, the seafood selection includes dishes featuring shrimp, scallops, salmon, tuna, and grouper, alongside options for the non-seafood eaters in your group.
Our tip: Keep Hurricane Hanks in mind when you’re staying in Holmes Beach and want an easy dining option nearby. Depending on your rental’s location, you may even be able to walk.
Seafood Restaurants in Cortez
While there are plenty of seafood restaurants on Anna Maria Island, a few nearby spots deserve a place in your plans, too.
Head across the bridge from Bradenton Beach, and you’ll find the Historic Cortez Village, one of the last working commercial fishing villages on the Gulf. Here are three places we recommend grabbing a bite:

8. Star Fish Company
At Star Fish Company, the setting is a big part of why you go.
The business began as a seafood company in the 1920s, expanded into a retail market, and later added a dockside restaurant. Today, you can enjoy seafood beside the waterfront, with boats and bay views.
The seafood market is another reason to visit. If you have a kitchen at your vacation rental, you can also check what’s available to bring home for dinner.
9. Swordfish Grill & Tiki Bar
Want to make an afternoon or evening of it? Swordfish Grill & Tiki Bar combines seafood, views of Sarasota Bay, and live music in Cortez.
The waterfront deck gives you a reason to linger, while the entertainment schedule can help you choose when to visit. It’s an option for a family dinner, a meal with friends, or a relaxed stop after exploring the fishing village.
Check the daily specials before ordering, and leave some room in your schedule to enjoy the setting.
10. Tide Tables
Tide Tables is another Cortez spot to save. Its menu includes fresh Gulf grouper, shrimp, scallops, and mahi-mahi, with several dishes available fried, grilled, or blackened.
The waterfront setting gives you plenty to watch while you eat, from passing boats to birds around the docks. Order lunch, enjoy the view, and give yourself permission to stay a little longer.
Our tip: Ask about the daily Captain’s Special, and consider finishing with homemade Key lime pie.

Visiting in Fall? Keep Stone Crab Season on Your Radar
Fall on Anna Maria Island comes with warm beach days, local events, and another reason to plan a seafood dinner: stone crab season.
Florida’s stone crab harvest season runs from October 15 through May 1, making a fall or winter getaway a good time to look for these seasonal claws.
At Blue Marlin, locally caught stone crab brought in with Captain Mike’s Charters is a seasonal highlight to watch for. Check the restaurant’s current offerings when planning your meal, since availability depends on the catch.
If stone crab is on your vacation wish list, ask what’s available before you go and make your dinner plans early. Fresh catches and seasonal specials are part of what makes eating here fun, and you may discover something different on your next visit.



Stay Close to Your Next Favorite Restaurant
The only thing better than finding a great seafood spot is knowing you have time to try a few more before heading home.
With a vacation rental, you can settle into the island routine: coffee in the morning, a few hours at the beach, and dinner somewhere you’ve been looking forward to all day. You’ll also have a kitchen for the nights you want to bring home fresh seafood and enjoy a quieter evening.
At Mike Norman Realty, we’ve been helping guests plan Anna Maria Island stays for over 45 years. From beach cottages to homes with private pools, our rentals give you a comfortable place to return to after exploring the island’s restaurants.
Browse our Anna Maria Island vacation rentals, book directly with our local team, and start making your seafood wish list.
