Top 10 Anna Maria Island Restaurants

While everybody loves what they know, it’s always fun to get out of the kitchen and try something new while on vacation. Anna Maria is a great place to experiment with new kinds of food, with many options right at the front door of Anna Maria Island vacation rentals.

Enjoy fresh seafood, excellent cuts of meat, flavorful tacos, and super subs during your time on Anna Maria Island – there’s something for everyone.

Here is a list of the 10 best restaurants on Anna Maria Island:

#1 – Blue Marlin Seafood

Blue Marlin Seafood offers the freshest seafood on Anna Maria Island with a fun, family atmosphere. You can often hear live music wafting from their outdoor courtyard, and the central location makes it a popular place to eat. Located on Bridge Street, you can walk to shops, play mini golf, then stroll into the restaurant for your choice of fish, steak, burgers, and more!

blue marlin restaurant anna maria

#2 – Beach Bistro

Location: 6600 Gulf Dr.

The Beach Bistro is a fine dining staple on the island. It has delicious American and seafood and is located right along the beach. Order a table and have a cocktail on the beach while you wait.

The Beach Bistro slants upscale, and the main courses represent the pinnacle of Florida seafood dining in a romantic atmosphere.


#3 – The Waterfront Restaurant

Location: 111 S. Bay Blvd.

AMI’s Waterfront Restaurant is a casual-fine dining restaurant that works to create innovation dishes with natural flavors. Its menu consists of seafood entrees and both international American classics crafted with care and ingenuity. Enjoy scenic patio dining with a water view in two separate patio areas, accommodations for large groups indoor and out, and a versatile rotating menu that will have you craving more.

The Waterfront Restaurant is open from 11:30 a.m. to 9 p.m. with an additional hour to 10 p.m. on Fridays and Saturdays.

#4 – The Sandbar Restaurant

Location: 100 Spring Ave.

Dip your toes in the sand while enjoying some delicious food at The Sandbar Restaurant. The Sandbar is located right on the beach and specializes in succulent steak and fresh seafood. Because of its picture-perfect location and proximity to the beach, The Sandbar is an island hot spot for weddings and other private parties and cultural events.

You can find the doors to the Sandbar Restaurant open every day from 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Interestingly, the Sandbar opens an extra hour early at 10 a.m. on Sundays to accommodate big breakfast and brunch crowds.

#5 – Anna Maria Oyster Bar

There are several locations to choose from, but you can get the same amazing menu items at any of them. The Anna Maria Oyster Bar is a staple of island cuisine for many years, and it is hard to beat the deals they offer throughout the week.

#6 – Island Ocean Star

Ocean Star Sushi has one of the best waterfront views along with incredible food. Overlooking Bimini Bay, this Japanese restaurant offers a large selection of sushi in a laid-back fine dining atmosphere. Hibachi menu items are also available for family members that prefer turf rather than surf.

ocean star sushi anna maria

$7 – eat here Anna Maria

Location: 5315 Gulf Dr.

eat here intended to be less expensive and less formal fine-dining than its nearby competitors, and was launched by the owners of award-winning Beach Bistro as a sister restaurant. It whips up slightly more casual versions of some Beach Bistro’s best-loved dishes.

It is open from 5:30 p.m. to 10 p.m., similar to its older sibling restaurant, the Beach Bistro.

#8 – The Feast

Located in Holmes Beach, The Feast offers American seafood with a twist. Offering signature classics and imported ingredients from around the world, this restaurant may provide something you can’t get back home. If you love trying something new and unique, this is definitely a restaurant that you don’t want to miss.

#9 – Duffey’s Tavern

Location: 5808 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach
Hours:Monday – Saturday 11 a.m. – 8 p.m. | Closed Tuesday | Sunday 12 p.m. – 8 p.m.

Also known as hamburger heaven, welcome to the place that offers “the coldest beer in town.” Duffey’s Tavern might make some bold statements with their food, but it is a favorite of both visitors and locals for a reason.

Family-owned and operated for 40 years, has given Pat Geyer and her five daughters a lot of time to perfect the flavors and vibe of the restaurant. With ideal patio areas for outside dining, you can head there straight from the beach still wearing your bathing suit.

duffey's tavern anna maria

#10 – Poppo’s Taqueria

Location: 212C Pine Ave.

It’s no surprise that Poppo’s Taqueria is often busy. As one of the only authentic Mexican restaurants in the area, Poppo’s makes a mean taco, quesadilla, burrito or bowl and has locations all over the region. Think of it as a big step up from Chipotle.

This authentic eatery is open from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. every day of the week.

poppos tacos anna maria

Mike Norman Realty, Inc.

Sign Up for Our Vacation Rental Newsletter

3101 Gulf Drive
Holmes Beach, Florida USA 34217

Anna Maria, Florida
Weather from OpenWeatherMap

Learn More About Our Rental Management Program