The Best Burger Joints on Anna Maria Island

Anna Maria Island, Florida, is a paradise for foodies. You can find delicious seafood from the Gulf of Mexico, mouthwatering pastries made fresh every day, and unique coffee blends from local cafes.

But sometimes, you get the craving for a juicy burger. If that’s the case, you’re in luck! There are tons of Anna Maria Island restaurants putting their own unique twists on this classic dish. Book one of our Anna Maria Island vacation rentals and see for yourself!

Duffy’s Tavern

Duffy’s Tavern has been an Anna Maria Island staple since it opened its doors in 1958. Although the eatery is in a different building than where it opened, its fans have followed it to its current location. You’ll find the atmosphere casual and welcoming to every guest, inviting you to come as you are and enjoy some top-quality food.

Once you try a burger at Duffy’s, you’ll understand why USA Today named this eatery as one of the country’s 10 top “hamburger heavens”! Of course, you can get classics like the traditional hamburger, cheeseburger, or bacon cheeseburger. But if you’re feeling adventurous, try a unique option like the brie and caramelized onion cheeseburger, the Tex Burger (with BBQ sauce!), or the mushroom and Swiss burger. 

Visit Duffy’s Tavern at 5808 Marina Drive in Holmes Beach. 

Skinny’s Place

If you’re asking the locals about the best restaurants on Anna Maria Island, don’t be surprised if you get recommendations for Skinny’s Place. This restaurant has welcomed customers since 1952, and generations of families have come in to experience the magic. You can’t miss the building when you come upon it; look for the bright blue railing around the deck! 

All burgers here at Skinny’s Place are quarter pounders made daily with fresh beef, so you won’t have to worry about leaving hungry! Get a classic Skinny Hamburger or Cheeseburger, or add a second patty to make it a Fatty Hamburger or Cheeseburger. If you’re a cheese lover, check out the G3, made with three kinds of cheese! They even offer a veggie burger to satisfy the vegetarians in your group.

Skinny’s Place is located at 3901 Gulf Drive in Holmes Beach. 

The Ugly Grouper

You might not expect to find a great burger at a restaurant with fish in the name, but you’d be surprised by what you’ll find at The Ugly Grouper! Come and enjoy a laid-back meal with a beautiful view from the patio. Be sure to take your picture with the Grouper Statue while you’re here!

Of course, the Classic Burger is a great option. You’ll get a half-pound of Angus, brisket, and short rib on a brioche bun with toppings like lettuce, pickles, and tomato. For something a bit more unique, consider the Smokehouse Patty Melt. This tempting dish features their signature burger patty topped with barbecue pulled port and your choice of cheese. Is your mouth watering yet?

Plan Your Visit!

Whenever you book an Anna Maria Island vacation rental with Mike Norman, you’re never far from a delicious restaurant to enjoy! View our rentals, book your favorite, and prepare for a wonderful getaway!

You’ll likely need a nap after chowing down on one of the best burgers on Anna Maria Island! That’s where we come in. Mike Norman is happy to provide Anna Maria Island rentals to groups of all sizes, no matter where you wish to stay on the island. You’ll access amenities like high-speed internet, fully stocked kitchens, and more! You can even book an Anna Maria Island vacation rental with a pool! Contact Mike Norman Realty today to learn more and to book your stay.